Food for thought
Interesting! When I was a track racer, we did a similar test with power meters using clipless pedals vs old-fashioned toe clips. Slight advantage with clipless (toe clips straps were fastened down TIGHT). Riding a fixed gear at high RPMs requires being locked in, IMO.food for thought
(Unrelated....does @Ron or anyone recall a crankset that “made” each leg pedal separately? In other words, turning one side didn’t turn the other, so pedaling required full effort from both legs....after using one in training, I was amazed at how much weaker my left leg was).
Tell me more! Ever since my ACL surgery, my "dominant" side's quad has been significantly smaller than my supposedly non-dominant side. I just can't get the dominant quad to recruit fully.
And @Monique ....it was so long ago, I can’t recall the name....but it is on the tip of my tongue!tell me about it! since my hip was shut down for so long, my left quad is so much smaller. I still do pt stuff to get the muscles to recruit properly. Not much you can do but keep working at it and be mindful when peddling. Do extra strengthening on the weaker leg.
@Wendy I have a few Pt prescribed tricks that get my glutes to fire. At times skiing or riding, I have to stop and do them to get things to fire.
tell me about it! since my hip was shut down for so long, my left quad is so much smaller. I still do pt stuff to get the muscles to recruit properly. Not much you can do but keep working at it and be mindful when peddling. Do extra strengthening on the weaker leg.
It's really all personal preference I think. I personally can't stand riding without clipless. I get it though if you don't like it. I don't really think that any of us (or most of us anyway..) are really worried about 315w vs 310w. If you feel comfortable on flats, go for it. Will that extra 0.2% of power get you over that rock garden?? Maybe..but maybe platforms will give you the confidence to try. It's really like the bar-end debate..use what works for you.
food for thought
Interesting. These guys are fun presenters.
I was not convinced by their earlier lab experiment, but still interesting stuff to play with.
I'd like to see one of these that incorporates a challenging three to five hour ride over real terrain somehow. In other words, I suspect that relatively small gains in efficiency are important over long hard efforts, but probably not over ten minutes.
Elaborate??
And @Monique ....it was so long ago, I can’t recall the name....but it is on the tip of my tongue!
I’ll ask my bike shop guy. He will know. It was a big thing with track cyclists around here.
@Ron, I too have difficulty with getting some of the muscles in my left leg to fire completely and have a bit of atrophy in my left quad.
I did that one-legged stuff back when I was competitive. It would do me good to build up to being able to do it again. These days, I ride my hard tail mountain bike most of the time.Have any of you tried one-legged averages?
Roughly they go like this:
Ride an hour at a relaxed pace, enough to get an average speed on your comp. Finish the hour near a flattish 1-2 mile section.
Now, with only one leg clipped in, ride that mile while sustaining your average speed. Do NOT let the speed drop below your average. Turn around, ride back with the other leg.
Most reasonably fit riders should be able to do that in the middle cogs. In the larger cogs, up-down posting will get severely punished. In the smaller cogs it will hammer the hamstrings - expect cramps.
I have a set of Powercranks but herself never put the time in on the indoor trainer to get used to them enough to take them on the road.
OLAs are much cheaper, require zero drivetrain work and no indoor build-up to outdoor riding.
I did that one-legged stuff back when I was competitive. It would do me good to build up to being able to do it again. These days, I ride my hard tail mountain bike most of the time.
What are OLA’s?
Have any of you tried one-legged averages?
Roughly they go like this:
Ride an hour at a relaxed pace, enough to get an average speed on your comp. Finish the hour near a flattish 1-2 mile section.
Now, with only one leg clipped in, ride that mile while sustaining your average speed. Do NOT let the speed drop below your average. Turn around, ride back with the other leg.
Most reasonably fit riders should be able to do that in the middle cogs. In the larger cogs, up-down posting will get severely punished. In the smaller cogs it will hammer the hamstrings - expect cramps.
I have a set of Powercranks but herself never put the time in on the indoor trainer to get used to them enough to take them on the road.
OLAs are much cheaper, require zero drivetrain work and no indoor build-up to outdoor riding.
And now I realize why these won't work for me. You have to be in clipless pedals.