Here in New England, REI competes with EMS (Eastern Mountain Sports). My local EMS store is small, so not really worth visiting…. The nearest REI is 40, 50 minutes away so I rarely get there.
EMS had closed all their stores in the flat land. I can't say I missed them.
Actually, I missed them when they closed, which was something like 10 years back. When I talked to the sales staff at the local store, I was told they didn't get to choose what they put on the floor. So lots of ski stuff and not enough kayaking stuff here in Connecticut. Little wonder they did poorly.
REI is more conscious of local particulars. That helps. Unfortunately, they've lost their uniqueness in the market place. They used to have the best and latest hiking/camping/backpacking gear. Now, though they still carry a lot of good stuff, but not the best any more. I think it's their buyers. Here, even in the flagship New York Soho store, which
should attract a lot of type-A big spenders with ultra light backpacking gear etc, the stuff they put on the floor were pretty pedestrian. I can see plainly the frustration of the sale staff who had to tell me to get what I need from competitors online.