Following up with a half-baked epilogue.
The Carli oil did arrive, after a kerfuffle around the shipping. (See screenshot from around August 9.) Basically their customer service is, shall we say, Italian.
(Note that my heritage allows me to make this slam in public.)
Eventually I did a very informal tasting with what
@cantunamunch calls "Herself". It was somewhat inconclusive, mostly because we didn't have a bottle of our standard-bearer Portuguese Cobrancosa as a control. Also, as you will have seen, I did not manage to scrounge up matching dishes for color comparisons.
Three of the four oils in the photo are labeled "Organic." (The Carli is the outlier here.) We thought all four were tasty and none was off-putting. Bottom line is that the Whole Foods blend blew away the others as a value proposition. Going forward, after we use all this stuff up, I think I'm going to stock the Cobrancosa (not pictured) as a "special" bottle for toppings and stick with the Whole Foods for everything else.
PS: How could the "Paesano" NOT be a Mob product?