· Killington or Okemo - Killington. If you care about skiing over "total experience" It's not even close. Okemo has very nice facilities, but every run feels like a very slightly steeper, or slightly less steep version of the same flat blue cruiser.
· Mt Snow or Stratton - Stratton. I like both well enough for "close" VT mountains. Slight edge to Stratton on the skiing.
· Stowe or Smugglers Notch - Stowe, just for the size and amount of terrain compared to Smugs. I love the mountain, but don't love that it's now part of the Vail empire. I also love Smugs, and would love it even more if there was a better lift system.
· Sugarbush or Mad River - Sugarbush. Along with Stowe, my favorite place to ski in VT.
· Catamount or Jiminy Peak - Jiminy I guess. I'd prefer to keep driving past both.
· Hunter or Windham - Hunter. This is the Killington vs. Okemo of the Catskills. Windham has much nicer facilities and is a nicer experience. Hunter has significantly better terrain.
· Bromley or Magic - Magic.
· Bretton Woods or Wildcat - I've skied neither
· Loon or Waterville - I've skied neither