Not exactly your tire, however I previously ran the Scorpion winters, and then last winter switched to the Dunlop SP Wintersport 3D. I was happy with the Pirellis and was skeptical of the switch- I am admittedly a tire snob. At the time, the dealer only had the Dunlop as an option for my car. In any case, I was really happy with the ride and performance of the new Dunlops. No slipping, and tons of grip on ice and snow. I was 100% happy with them. In fact I kept them on for the entire year and didn't buy a new set of warmer weather rubber this year. The Dunlops rode well all year long. There is plenty of tread left for me this winter.