A frivolous poll while we're waiting for snow: Mayo or Miracle Whip?

[Tricia]

At the suggestion of @dbostedo
I have my own strong feelings about this, but I'll leave it up to the poll to decide.

Spoiler

Psst.... I'm a huge Mayo fan over MW. Our household prefers Hellman's (known as Best Foods west of the Rockies)

 

[Core2]

Miracle Whip tastes like rotten Mayo to me.

 

[surfsnowgirl]

Mayo but full disclosure, I've never tried Miracle Whip.

 

[dbostedo]

At the suggestion of @dbostedo
I have my own strong feelings about this, but I'll leave it up to the poll to decide.

Oh, I know which one is going to win... I just wonder by how much. Miracle Whip is, regrettably, doomed to lose.

Maybe we need to add a "Never tried Miracle Whip" option? Just to see how many people have been deprived of how much better it is than mayo.

 

[scott43]

 

[Decreed_It]

Duke's
there are no others worthy of mention

There IS Durkee Famous Sauce though.

 

[Drahtguy Kevin]

Depends what it's going on/in. Most of the time Miracle Whip for me.

 

[SBrown]

Duke's
there are no others worthy of mention

I like mayo so much I have Duke's AND Hellmann's/Best Foods in my fridge.

 

[Blue Streak]

Avocado mayo.mmmmmmmmm

 

[Blue Streak]

Depends what it's going on/in. Most of the time Miracle Whip for me.

 

[Josh Matta]

My wife makes homemade mayo, I turn it into homemade miracle whip.

FYI the best Mayo on the planet is Lone Star cilantro jalapeno mayo the stuff they put on their fish tacos.

 

[dbostedo]

I turn it into homemade miracle whip.

What all do you add?

 

[Josh Matta]

sugar, parika and garlic powder will get you 95 percent there. For the base mayo I recommend using a tasteless oil and not say olive and or avocado oil.

 

[Sibhusky]

Miracle Whip because it's got more "zing" to it.

 

[chilehed]

Mayo for sure. The other is too sweet and too acidic, and if I want sweet acidic mayo I prefer to be able to control that myself.

 

[coskigirl]

My dad's homemade mayo. I don't eat enough mayo to even justify buying, much less making my own from his recipe but it includes oil, egg, dijon, and lemon juice. It's so delicious.

 

[Philpug]

I could not image having anything but mayo on...

• BLT
• Egg Salad
• Roast beef sandwich
• Liverwurst sandwich
• Tunafish

 

[dbostedo]

I could not image having anything but mayo on...

• BLT
• Egg Salad
• Roast beef sandwich
• Liverwurst sandwich
• Tunafish

• BLT - Much better with Miracle Whip (and somewhat crispy bacon)
• Egg Salad - I don't think I've ever had it, but I like Tuna Salad with a lot of egg
• Roast beef sandwich - Definitely better with Miracle Whip, but could be even better with jus or maybe a little Worcestshire or steak sauce
• Liverwurst sandwich - I've never had Liverwurst... sounds gross
• Tunafish - Tuna Salad with Miracle Whip and lots of egg is awesome... a tuna steak sandwich is better with just some seasoning - defintiely not mayo and probably not Miracle Whip

 

[CS2-6]

Mayo is an ingredient. Miracle Whip is a condiment.

 

[Josh Matta]

Horseradish mayo on roast beef....always